Final Reflection
According to data provided by the National Assessment of Educational Progress, only 33% of eighth-graders passed a national grade-level math test. In 2013, 36% percent of eighth-graders passed the assessment. This statistic also remains consistent with Americans of all ages. According to The Washington Post, Americans score significantly worse on numeracy tests than countries like Japan, Finland, Sweden, and Germany. The data I collected is highly shocking. Earlier this year, my class discussed how Americans teach math. We concluded that American teachers focus on covering material rather than comprehension. This class discussion prompted my interest in this issue. I believe that the main reason Americans perform poorly on math is due to the teaching strategies used in elementary and middle schools. Excellent elementary and middle school math classes are essential in creating a firm foundation to mature from. I have found that these courses do not give students enough variety, which weakens their ability to conceptualize the information.
Major steps in my project-
- Research- I researched during three class periods. This phase was a little bit difficult because originally, I wanted to study why American education emphasizes quickness, summarized in the blog post that I’ve linked. After reflecting outside of class, I decided to change my topic to the American math curriculum and why students score poorly on numeracy tests. I researched the average test scores of Americans and compared them to scores of people in other countries. https://ellah1111.edublogs.org/2021/04/28/research-reflection/
- Recognizing the problem- After researching, I saw that Americans score well in every core subject except for math. There is something wrong with how Americans teach math. https://ellah1111.edublogs.org/2021/04/29/the-problem-with-american-education/
- Receiving feedback from my classmates- Consulting my classmates was a massive part in helping me narrow down the issue I wanted to approach. I spoke to two other students, Maggie and Mallory. When I proposed the problem, they started to talk about their experiences in elementary school. Mallory and Maggie both agreed that they struggled with basic multiplication because they tried to memorize the solution to the problem instead of processing it. https://ellah1111.edublogs.org/2021/05/05/peer-interview/
- Reflecting on feedback, research, and personal experiences to create a solution- After considering everything that I’ve learned and experiences, I decided that more variety was the answer to better understanding math. I aimed my attention at elementary and middle school education because these grades teach essential math skills. https://ellah1111.edublogs.org/2021/05/07/prototype/
- Presenting my prototype- My prototype was a multiplication worksheet or assessment that uses more variety. I compared my model to a regular multiplication practice. Like most people, I have always struggled with presenting in front of an audience. Even though I was anxious, I think I presented well. I can improve on talking slower and taking my time. https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1nUsE2fyC3_V_CEwQ6cEpTZS5t_7_iUwpE37Xmy_EnCQ/edit?usp=sharing
What went well-
I think the prototyping phase went very well for me because I have experience with tutoring young students. Last year, I tutored several 6th-grade Episcopal students. I noticed that their lesson plans and assessments had not changed since I was in 6th grade four years ago. Worksheets and assessments lacked variety and usually only stuck to one method. Many of the issues that I saw globally were also prevalent in the students. I noticed that students are too busy trying to remember the procedure rather than taking their path independently.
What could have gone better-
During my research phase, I was still trying to pick a specific topic, so my research was not as straightforward as it could have been. I wish I researched the psychology of how children learn. I think that would have been an interesting touch to add to my project.
I wish I worked on my project outside of school more. I had an AP exam on May 5th, which occupied most of my time. I think this serves as an example that I still need to improve in time management.
What I learned-
After I presented, Chris prompted a question of how my prototype would be implemented. I’ve learned that implementing a new teaching strategy for math is very difficult because it has been taught the same way for decades. My solution would be challenging to implement because it requires teachers to put more effort into creating and changing the layout of their assignments.
How I read my final book at the end of the year vs. the beginning of the year-
In the first quarter of the school year, I read Normal People for my independent reading book. If I’m honest, I finished the book within the last two days before it was due. I focused on finishing the book rather than processing it, so I wasn’t able to recall some parts of the plot. It was very rough. I learned that this was not something that I wanted to do again. As I said earlier, I had an AP exam around the same time that I was reading my final independent book, This Earth of Mankind. I didn’t read as frequently as I should have, but I made more time reading This Earth of Mankind than I did for Normal People. When I finished my exam, I became more dedicated to reading my book and finished it in about a week. Although this process wasn’t perfect, it was much more effective because I had more time understanding the book.
The most significant theme of Mrs. Duke’s English III class is independence. This project completely exemplifies this theme. I loved this project because my class was given the freedom to choose an issue we were passionate about and find a way to solve it. English III has shown me that independence teaches students time management and creativity. If I had more time to work on this project, I would create a lesson plan to go along with my solution to changing the format of math problems. Younger students would benefit from a classroom like Mrs. Duke’s. Students deserve to have confidence, creativity, and freedom.
Works Cited
“International Student Assessment (PISA) – Mathematics Performance (PISA) – OECD Data.” The OECD, data.oecd.org/pisa/mathematics-performance-pisa.htm#indicator-chart.
Rampell, Catherine. “Americans Are Pretty Bad at Math. Especially Young Americans.” The Washington Post, WP Company, 30 Mar. 2019, www.washingtonpost.com/news/rampage/wp/2015/02/04/americans-are-pretty-bad-at-math-especially-young-americans/.
Venezky, Elie. “Here’s Why the United States Is So Bad at Math.” U.S. News & World Report, U.S. News & World Report, 4 May 2018, www.usnews.com/news/best-countries/articles/2018-05-04/commentary-heres-why-the-united-states-is-so-bad-at-math.